Some Quality Time with Mr. Gordo
Sseason 2 EpisodeWhat’s My Line Part 1 and 2This episode is written with no consideration for plausibility and every consideration for forwarding character’s emotional storyarcs. Jane Espensen, a writer for Buffy, has a great website that gives advice to would-be TV writers on how to write a spec script to get into the business. In one post she advises that writers should start with an emotional moment or action that a character is not likely to have and then write the spec script to answer the question “what would have to happen for x to happen?” So, it seems like the script for this two part series was written sort of like that — there are a LOT Of payoffs in this episode in terms of the buffyverse mythology, characters emotional lives, and actions. Many many things happen and that kind of distracts you from the fact that it’s all just a little too neat.To my mind, the main story arc here, the one that doesn’t feel contrived — is that Spike finally figures out how to get Drusilla cured of her wasting sickness. Of course she needs the blood of Angel (her sire), thus emperiling Buffy’s main emotional support. We also find out that there’s a second slayer b/c of Buffy’s brief death. But the way they introduced her was completely contrived. It’s as though the question was: what would have to happen for the second slayer and Buffy to get in a fight? Make her think Buffy was a vampire which means Buffy has to kiss Angel in vamp face while Kendra (the 2nd slayer) sees them. Kendra is completely stiff and unbelievable and I’m glad they killed her off at the end of the season. I blame this on the fact that they were trying to show that slayers were a worldwide phenom while at the same time giving her this bookish character. So they made her Jamaican (the actress had listed on her resume that she could do Jamaican accents) but also someone who only has one shirt. Now, I found out recently that this actress was originally cast as Cordelia(!) but couldn’t take the part for whatever reason. I suppose she must actually be a good actress, and as I watched the episode again, I tried to imagine what her lines would have been like if they’d been played by someone more nerdy, someone not completely stilted b/c they were trying to stick to this crappy accent and it made the episode a lot better.2. Xander and Cordelia kiss — I actually love this, and I think that they set it up pretty well in some of the preceding episodes, having them seek each other out to bicker, almost, and also having them realize that the two people that they are actually really attracted to (Buffy and Angel) were completely into each other (in Halloween). Of course, the only thing that would make Cordelia and Xander kiss is to trap them in a basement after attacking them with a “man of bugs”. This actually foreshadows Buffy and Angel’s sexual encounter where they are so freaked out by their encounter with the Judge that they have to have sex (hey man, Joss said it, not me).3. Willow and Oz finally meet — and we find out that they are basically the two smartest people in the school and therefore, meant for each other. I love Oz. The final thing that I found annoying about this episode was that the Order of Tarraka, or whatever, was set up to be this enormous juggernaut that would never stop coming for Buffy. But then, they kill three of them, and they stop coming. Why? It’s one of the problems with the show is that each successive villain has to be so much more dangerous in order to get us to be afraid or to put Buffy in peril that when it is defeated, it’s a little of a let down. Hence the brilliance of making the next villain be Angel.
January 25, 2008 at 2:13 pm
OK, I just wasted 30 secs of my life creating an acct so I can get back to making comments…
So, Kendra, The Vampire Slayer….I really hate this character!!!!!!!!! And I was also grateful that she got killed off, I mean lets face it…Faith is so much better! I think that she might want to consider removing the Jamaican accent from her resume, it’s about as believable as mine, which I developed from watching Cool Runnings. Also, I just can’t picture her as Cordelia…I think that role was made for Charisma.
I think that Oz was one of the best characters in the show, it’s a shame that he wasn’t in it for longer. I think that Angel becoming the villain was a stroke of Genius.
Anyway, I need to grade some tests….
June 8, 2009 at 3:41 pm
Found your blog by chance, and I have to say, it’s been really great reading your thoughts on Buffy. I recently took a class (I’m an undergrad) on the show, and was bitterly disappointed in the level of discourse, which consisted of “Drusilla represents a ‘bad girl.’ Willow represents a ‘good girl.’ Buffy represents a ‘good girl that can be bad.’” It was pretty horrible, considering I was hoping for something like this.
Anyway, your take on Spike as a parallel to Buffy (Spike is to vampires what Buffy is to Slayers) is brilliant; I never thought of it in that light. Kendra’s purpose though, I think, was a bit more complicated than just hitting viewers in the face with the fact that there are countless others outside of Sunnydale who are involved and aware of the Slayer and all that comes with it. I agree that the actress was stiff and her accent atrocious, but I always saw her as foil to Buffy. Raised by a Watcher and bred specifically to the Watcher’s Council’s expectations and wishes, she represents what a Slayer supposedly should be, according to the hierarchy’s rules. However, in comparison to Buffy, who because of her emotional connections is stronger and more effective than Kendra (It’s not insignificant that while Buffy manages to resist the Master’s thrall, Kendra submits to Drusilla’s, arguably a much weaker vampire than the Master), it is shown that not only are these rules and regulations (the “Slayer handbook,” as Giles mentions he threw out upon first meeting Buffy) are outdated, but that the Council itself is out of touch and, being the authority on Slayers, doesn’t even truly understand the nature or how to truly wield that power. It’s the first hint of the Council being shown as misguided and foolish – arrogance without any real reason to be so – and foreshadows further conflicts between Buffy and co. and the Council.
I’m a little skeptical at the news that what’shername was originally cast as Cordelia. I’ve seen her in other parts (most memorably, she played a semi-love interest/foil to Dawson on Dawson’s Creek) and she’s…passable, I guess. The stiffness never really leaves, though, so I think that’s just her, rather than a direction for Kendra’s character. But anyway.
Just wanted to share my thoughts. Don’t know if you’re still around, but I wanted to drop you a line anyway.