Season 2 — Episode 4: Inca Mummy Girl
This is a really sweet episode. It continues to explore the idea of evil actions done by people who are pressed into bad choices due to intolerable circumstances.
The plot here is that an ancient Incan Princess was called to be a sacrifice for her people at the age of 16. She was killed and mummified and then, in the 20th century, discovered and brought on a tour of museums. The ancient shield holding her in place was broken and she escapes and proceeds to suck the life out of a series of men to return and maintain her human appearance.
And she and Xander fall in love.
Ampata — as she calls herself after the innocent and good-natured foreign exchange student she ruthlessly slays (I feel so sorry for him) is a really sweet and beautiful girl who was chosen against her will. She provides a counterpoint to Buffy, who, like Impada, was called to die for the benefit of her people. But, unlike Buffy, who despite a certain ambivalence to her role as Slayer, does actually choose to do it (remember the finale of Season 1) over and over again, even though she doesn’t like it, it doesn’t seem like Ampata actually made peace with her role as Chosen One. And once she gets a taste of a normal life, she will kill anyone that stands in her way — even the person she claims to love — Xander.
The emotional arc continues to explore the Xander/Willow relationship–hammering home the idea that Willow loves Xander and he continues to see her as just a friend. We also see Willow wrestling with the realization that Xander is never going to like her. And we also meet Oz for the first time who shows us that he really gets Willow by falling for her in her Eskimo costume. See, there’s lots of sweetness.
But by far the sweetest scene is the end scene where Xander sums up the differences between Ampata and Buffy. We realize that, even though she bitches about it a lot, Buffy does actually choose day after to day to be the chosen one and to take the sacrifices and petty annoyances that come with it. She doesn’t shirk her duty. We know it now after this episode because we see, in Ampata, what it looks like for someone to make the wrong choices.
That ability to Show rather than Tell the differences between good and bad choices — is one of the real strengths of the early seasons of Buffy and it’s one that we start to lose about halfway through the 3rd season as the show starts to talk too much. But that’s a discussion for another time. Here, the real emotional pay off of this episode is that we finally have Buffy acknowledging to Xander, in a real way, that he was the one who brought her back from the dead.